Tag Archives: crime

Book twenty-one: Strip Jack #Rankin

The 4th book in the Rebus series sees our leading character back in Edinburgh and in a new relationship with Dr Patience Atkin.  Rebus is without a doubt more comfortable in his native Edinburgh and in this book I would say he is at his most stable so far.  That said, it wouldn’t be Rebus if there weren’t dark clouds up ahead and doubts about his future, or more specifically his and Patience’s future.  Forever tied to his job and unable to put his love life first I found it amusing that a decision about whether to move in with Patience is weighted by whether he continues to be based at the Greater London Road police station or moved to St Leonards.  For those who’ve read subsequent or more recent Rebus books…well you know the outcome.

Of the Rebus books so far I would say Strip Jack is the more straight forward “who dun nit” with a little bit of Rebus intuition thrown in.  The book starts with a raid on an Edinburgh brothel, where amongst the many punters the police find a popular young MP Gregor Jack.  Despite the secrecy of the raid upon exiting the building the road is lined with press.  Something about this doesn’t sit well with Rebus, it just seems too lucky for the press to be there.  When Jack’s wife Elizabeth disappears Rebus can’t help but feel there is a bigger game at foot and starts to explore the social and personal lives of Gregor and Elizabeth Jack and their friends.  A disappearance becomes a murder.  There is pressure on the police to quickly solve it but Rebus  isn’t convinced they’re following the right line of enquiry.  True to himself and like a dog with a bone Rebus won’t give up.  Was Gregor Jack set up? Who can be trusted? Where was Elizabeth murdered? Step by step Rebus unravels the story in a way only he can.

Without becoming uncontrollable in twists and turns there are enough red herrings and sub-plots in Strip Jack to keep us all guessing.  The cast is larger than previous books, giving Rankin an opportunity to develop more colourful and varied characters and in doing so giving Rebus more reflections to compare and judge himself against.  With this book we are seeing a world evolve around the Inspector.  In subsequent correspondence Ian Rankin has spoken about his decision with this book to take Rebus out of a fictional Edinburgh and into a more real one.  In the short series so far geography and in particular Edinburgh and its surrounding areas have proven to be a key building block of the books.  These books more so than any other series I have read place a city at its heart.  Edinburgh is as much a reoccurring character as Brian Holmes, Gill Templer, “Farmer Watson” and in the later books Siobhan Clarke and “Big Ger Cafferty”.  Whether it is the return from London, or this decision to make Edinburgh more real, in Strip Jack Rebus feels more grounded and secure in his role at the station, his stage in life and quite possibly in his romantic life.

It goes without saying that I’m a huge fan of Ian Rankin’s work, I wouldn’t be re-reading the series from start if I wasn’t.  I really enjoyed this book and felt like you could feel Rankin getting to grips with his plot structure, character development and starting to bring multiple dimensions to his main man.  A review of the book I recently read seemed to lament on the absence of the gruff, self-loathing critical rebel we know from later books.  If you’re not reading the books in order I can understand why someone would question Rebus’ approach in this book but I would say to them, start at the beginning, travel with him, because only then can you truly understand the infuriating loner who wins the sympathy of readers time and time again.



Leave a comment

Filed under Book review

Book eighteen: The Secret Broker #Crane

On first appearance Luca Voss is nothing more than an international playboy.  A fan of fast cars, gadgets and beautiful women.  But, underneath lies a highly skilled and trained secret agent in the employ of the ancient and secretive Seven Families.  When two of Voss’ colleagues including the lead agent “The Broker” are murdered he sets out to find out what they were working on and fights against the clock to prevent an international emergency.

From the opening chapter, when a Japanese ship is commandeered by mercenaries, kidnapping their smuggled passengers, I was hooked.  I had read that this was a must read for fans of John le Carre.  I’m actually not a fan of his, having read a few of his books I find them very slow, intellectually confusing and I get lost in the secrets like a child in Hampton Court Maze.  The Secret Broker is none of these things, it is fast paced, full of twists and turns and quick reveals.  You can read the entire book in the time in take le Carre’s character to order a drink at the bar.   So, if you’re a fan of le Carre maybe give it a miss but if you’re a fan of more modern mystery filled thrillers by the likes of Steve Berry, Chris Kuzneski and Raymond Khoury then this has to go on your to read list.

As a debut novel The Secret Broker is well written, Crane has done his research and his portrayal of the international political climate whilst manipulated to make his story is believable.  Similarly the back story to the power of the Seven Families is intriguing but not ludicrous ensuring the conspiracy doesn’t take over the book.

There is still some development of characters to be done and I hope to see more depth and consistency should the characters continue in subsequent books.  Voss is highly dependent on his assistance and lover JJ.  Whilst her power of seduction is key to her role, I don’t think the “romping” scenes with Voss and other characters brings much to the book.  If anything it made it feel dated,  a scene written to titillate the older male reader maybe?

The Secret Broker will not test your intelligence nor stimulate debate but like a good action film if you’re willing to suspend reality for a short period it’s a fantastic thriller with enough twists and turns to keep you guessing till the end.

I hope to see more of Luca Voss and the Seven Families in the future.

You can buy the book here

Leave a comment

Filed under Book review

Book thirteen: Watchmen #Moore #Gibbons

As discussed in an earlier blog Watchmen is the first graphic novel I’ve read.  Whilst I quickly got use to the format, finding it much easier and engaging than I had initially expected, I did struggle with getting my head around the story.  Unlike most novels there was no summary of the story available on the back cover and whilst my husband tried to give me a brief introduction I felt quite in the dark for the first few chapters.

So, having read it, what is it about?

Originally written as a series of comic books in 1986 and 1987 Watchmen is set in 1980s America, mostly true to the real world in setting but this one has superheroes who fight crime.  Although referred to as superheroes all bar one of them, Doctor Manhattan, are in fact just highly skilled, trained and equipped civilians, think Batman rather than Superman.  These costumed crime fighters together known as the Watchmen have in the preceding years to the start of the novel affected and altered the outcomes of key events in America’s history including the Vietnam War and presidency of Richard Nixon.  However, over time they have grown unpopular with the police and public leading to the Keene Act which in 1977 outlawed them.

The novel opens with the murder of Edward Blake, known as the Comedian who along with Doctor Manhattan had been operating as government-sanctioned agent since the introduction of the Keene Act.  Rorschach, who has been operating outside of the law believes there is a plot to terminate retired costumed adventurers and takes it upon himself to warn everyone.

Can he get to everyone in time? Who would want the heroes dead? And with the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan threatening to start World War III is there a place once more for masked avengers?

I found this to be quite a complex story, there is a lot of movement between the past and present as we learn about the different members of the Watchmen and it wasn’t always clear where in the timeline we were.  In the different chapters we jump back in time to find out more about how the characters developed their costumed alter egos, how they all met, what their relationship and friendships with each other were like.  At the end of chapters we are given access to additional material, extracts from autobiographies, newspaper clippings, letters etc. I believe these are there to give depth to the characters to flesh them out but I don’t think they quite succeed.  I felt that character development was lacking and I struggled to feel empathy or a connection with any of the characters.

Alongside the main story we have a young boy sat by a news cart reading a comic about pirates.  At no point within the story did I understand the relevance of this sub-plot.  I just found it frustrating and would often put down the book during those sections quickly losing interest.  Since finishing the book I have read explanations about the story within a story, how the author included it to bring a subtext and allegory about the darkness within man but even on reflection I fail to see any greater meaning or impact within the main story.

The title of the series apparently refers to the famous question by Juvenal “Who watches the watchmen?” and the theme of power and the role of “superheroes” within society is very strong in the book.  Power struggles between the heroes, US and Russia, between husband and wife, lovers, friends all of these are given a spotlight with the ultimate question being does power corrupt us or is manipulation and strength the only way to win in this world?

Leave a comment

Filed under Book review

Book eight: Tooth and Nail #Rankin

The 3rd novel in the Detective Rebus series sees our lead seconded to London to assist with a hunt for a cannibalistic serial killer nicknamed the Wolfman.  With his London colleagues less than pleased with his interference and distant connections between the case and his daughter Sammy’s new boyfriend Rebus needs to act quickly before the Wolfman’s taste for blood develops.

Having lived and worked in London for nearly a decade seeing Rebus work the boroughs and streets I’m more familiar with brought this story to life for me.  In particular his description of the troubled no go housing estates in East London and the vibrant but faceless streets of Soho and Piccadilly.  His grasp of places and ability to breathe life into them is a true literary skill.

This is the first of Rankin’s books where he starts to really explore the psychological make-up of his killer both through Rebus’s musings and more obviously through the assistance offered to the case by Lisa Frazer a student psychologist masking as a qualified Doctor who unintentionally marks herself out as a target for the crazed serial killer.  Rankin also gives us the reader a deeper insight to the Wolfman through chapters dedicated to thekiller’s narrative.  Exposed to the confused and tangled thoughts and actions of our serial killer Rankin is a master at making us think we know more than Rebus and yet leaving us completely in the dark as to the true nature, gender and identity of the Wolfman.

Tooth and Nail is also noted for the first reference of Morris Gerald Cafferty.  Initially just a cameo role he will go on to become Rebus’s chief adversary and major league gangster in Edinburgh.  I wonder if Rankin knew when Rebus went back to Scotland, in Tooth and Nail, to give evidence against Cafferty, that he would become such a major character in the subsequent books.

This is a fantastic mystery and like his previous novels Rankin has you turning page after page as your day just passes you by.  Don’t start this if you have a to-do list because believe me you won’t get the chores done.

Leave a comment

Filed under Book review, Uncategorized

Book five: Hide and Seek #Rankin

A junkie is found dead in a squat on one of Edinburgh’s sink estates. Laid out in a cross-like position, there are candles placed around him and a five-pointed star has been painted on the living room wall. Something about the case just doesn’t make sense to Rebus and as he begins his investigation it leads him to a dark and sleazy underworld of Edinburgh.

For this blog, rather than review the book I wanted to share the Introduction by Ian Rankin which is included in the 2008 re-publication of the book. I find it very interesting to hear an author speak about their work, their inspirations, influences and growth. In this introduction Rankin discusses things that influenced the writing of Hide and Seek, the interesting part being the influences he has only become aware of on reflection, for example the impact of his time spent living in London on his writing. It is also interesting to hear about how Rebus has grown and changed for Rankin. Across the years and many books Rankin has refined his main character, although refined is probably the wrong word as he remains rough around the edges.

I hope you enjoy reading Rankin’s thoughts as much I did.

Hide and Seek

An Introduction by Ian Rankin

A year or two after Hide and Seek was published, there was a break-in at Edinburgh’s police headquarters. Among the items rumoured to have been stolen was a list of names, the names of men prominent in Edinburgh society. Allegations had been made against these men, allegations that they had been using rent boys, leaving themselves open to blackmail, and a police inquiry had been instituted. There were enough similarities between the real-life case and aspects of my novel that people stopped me in the street to ask how I’d know so much so soon. I would explain that my sources had to be protected.

There were no sources, of course: I’d made the story up.

I saw Hide and Seek very much as a companion piece to Knots and Crosses. Reviewers had failed to pick up on the earlier book’s use of Robert Louis Stevenson’s The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde as a template. I was determined to try once more to drag Stevenson’s story back to its natural home of Edinburgh and to update the theme for a modern-day audience. In fact, the book’s eventual working title was ‘Hyde and Seek’, but only after I’d ditched ‘Dead Beat’ (at the behest of my agent, to whom the book was eventually dedicated). The final version of Hide and Seek opens with a quote from Jekyll and Hyde and goes on to use quotes from Stevenson’s book at the opening of each section. Moreover, I lifted many of the character names directly from Stevenson’s masterpiece – Enfield, Poole, Carew, Lanyon – while Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde provides Detective Inspector Rebus with his night-time reading, when he’s not busy mulling over his latest case.

Not that I was keen for readers to get the connection or anything…

Between Knots and Crosses and the events of Hide and Seek, Rebus has been promoted from detective sergeant – his one and only promotion in the series so far. Other changes have taken place. Rebus has a new sidekick called Brian Holmes (a none-too-subtle nod to another Edinburgh writer, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle). And Edinburgh is changing, too, as new money moves in. The book was written in 1988 and 1989. By then, I was living in London, at the height of Thatcherism. Red braces and Moet were all the rage. In some wine bars, rising property values seemed to be the only currency of conversation. I’d been living in London a couple of years and not making much of a go of it. My wife and I lived in a maisonette in Tottenham, and have failed to find full-time writing a lucrative enough proposition, I was working as a magazine journalist in Crystal Palace, entailing a three-hour commute each weekday. I seemed to be surrounded by people more successful than me, people with fat salaries or five-figure publishing deals. My situation at the time seem to me now to explain the bitted edge to much of the writing in Hide and Seek, and is reflected in Brian Holmes’s memories of his few student months in London (‘a season spent in hell’, as he himself remembers it).

The novel did not come hard on the heels of Knots and Crosses: there had been two other novels in between. One was a spy adventure, Watchman; the other, Westwind, was my attempt at a techno-thriller. The latter, however, was struggling to find a publisher of any kind, which the former had sold a scant five hundred copies in hardcover. Hide and Seek was actually begun in the summer of 1988, but failed to make much headway. My job got in the way, as did attempts to turn my first novel, The Flood, into a useable screenplay, and various frustrating efforts to get work as a scriptwriter on The Bill. I was also reviewing books most weeks for a new broadsheet called Scotland on Sunday.

One other reason why I may have held back on a second Rebus novel: plans had been afoot to film the first one, with Leslie Grantham (Dirty Den in EastEnders) as Rebus. This plan eventually fell through in January 1989. My guess had been than Grantham would want the action of Knots and Crosses relocated to London. Now that he would not be taking Rebus to the screen, I felt free to write a second Edinburgh-based adventure for my character. The final draught of the book was completed in May.

It’s a less overwrought work than its predecessor, the prose leaner, though the Rebus we meet is still not the fully formed character of later books. For one thing, he’s still too well-read quoting from Walt Whitman – someone I’d studied at university but of whom Rebus couldn’t really be expected to have had knowledge.   He also quotes from the Romantic poets and listens to Radio 3 in his car. On his hi-fi at home, there’s jazz, but also The Beatles’ White Album (I’d soon have him preferring the Stones). My own time as a hi-fi journalist is reflected in the expensive Linn turntable owned by one character, while a scene inside the library at the University of Edinburgh takes Holmes to the fifth floor, which I’d haunted during my three years as a postgraduate student.

There are other literary references in the book: to James Hogg’s The Private Memoirs and Confessions of a Justified Sinner and to the poet George MacBeth, who had shared a writers’ retreat with me a couple of years before. A character from The Flood pops up in the first few pages, and Rebus and Holmes both visit the west-central Fife, where the inspector and I grew up. It’s noticeable to me now that Rebus in particular is not as cynical about his old hunting ground as he was when paying his respects in Knots and Crosses. Maybe enough of my spleen had been vented. London was the enemy now – London, and the harsh materialism I seemed to have found there.

Besides, I had many happy memories of my childhood, memories rekindled by the death of my father in February 1990, while I was in the midst of proofreading Hide and Seek. By the time the book was ready for publication, Miranda and I had decidedly had enough of London and Mrs Thatcher. We were making plans to live in France, praying that my writing would start earning enough to turn the dream into a reality. And once we’d left Tottenham behind,    I’d be able to put some of my own feelings about the capital into words, by taking John Rebus to London on a case.

A case that would become Tooth and Nail.

A final word to the wise: there’s a question of sorts left hanging at the end of Hide and Seek. The curious will find an answer – also of sorts – at the end of chapter four of Resurrection Men. I only realised it was there when I reread the book recently. Don’t say I never share anything…


Leave a comment

Filed under Book review, Uncategorized

Book one: Knots & Crosses #Rankin

Knots & Crosses originally published in 1987 is the first of the incredibly successful Inspector Rebus novels by Ian Rankin. I was introduced to the series during my teenage years by an uncle who had the entire collection. Now I’m introducing my husband to them and taking the opportunity to re-read them myself.

In this first book Edinburgh has been rocked by the abduction and subsequent killing of two young girls. To those investigating there appears to be no link between the girls and no clear motive. Throwing man power at the enquiry John Rebus along with a number of colleagues is assigned to the investigative team. As a side story we are also introduced to Rebus’ brother Michael, a cabaret show hypnotist, small time drug dealer and focus of journalist Jim Stevens’ next big story. Throughout the case, John is haunted by his past in the SAS and an unknown person is sending him notes with bits of string and crosses. With more girls being abducted and killed can John put together the pieces to prevent the killer getting to those John loves?

As my adult reading has progressed I’ve developed a fondness for books that are set in areas that I know and where authors are true to the geography. I like to be able to follow the movements of a story as it plots it way across a city. It’s one of the things I love about Ben Aaronovitch’s Peter Grant series. On re-reading Rankin’s first novel I’ve come to realise it is quite possibly within his pages that this liking developed.  In this first novel he creates a perfect picture of Edinburgh in the late 1980s, a city that is above others, is grander, more refined and certainly not a place where hard hitting crime, like the abduction and murder of little girls, takes place. Rankin treats Edinburgh with the same care and attention he does his main characters ensuring the reader sees depth to the city understands the different faces of the city and recognises that its part in the storyline is more than just a map for events to be played out on. Edinburgh is Rebus and vice versa.

It is very easy to paint the picture of John Rebus in your head. A troubled man, he is gruff, unkempt, a chain smoker (although trying to quit), a drinker of sorts and a man of few words. John Rebus is definitely not a people person, and yet, within that moodiness is a vulnerable man and it is this side of Rebus that makes him such a compelling lead character and makes us care about him. We forgive his surly behaviour, his grumpiness, his personal demons because at the heart of the book Rankin reveals to us that Rebus cares. What matters to him is solving the crime, not necessarily the working out.

I’ve purposely not talk about the story for two reasons, the first, I don’t want to give anything away and secondly, I believe the importance of this first book is as a gateway into the world of Rebus, it is the Foundation upon which mighty tales will be built.

Leave a comment

Filed under Book review, Uncategorized